Carvana told you it's worth $28,400.
It's worth more.
Instant-offer services pay $1,500–$4,000 below private-party value on a typical car. That gap is the price of convenience — and convenience is overcharged. List on Motrix Marketplace and keep the spread.
You bring a $31,200 truck.
They write you a check for $28,400.
Carvana, CarMax, Peddle, and Vroom built a $20B category by being faster and easier than selling privately. Convenient — but the convenience is paid for in the spread between what they give you and what they sell it for.
That's just wholesale-to-retail. Question is which side of it you want to be on.
Same car. Different paths. Different paychecks.
Comps drawn from KBB private-party + CarGurus listings + completed eBay sales, mid-2026. Your number depends on condition, mileage, color, and local demand.
Where you're listing matters.
| Motrix | Carvana / CarMax | Facebook Marketplace | Cars.com / Autotrader | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Listing fee | $0 | N/A (they buy) | $0 | $25–$95 |
| Boost / promote upsells | None | N/A | Yes — buried unless paid | Aggressive |
| Pricing model | Private-party (full retail) | Wholesale ($1.5k–$4k under) | Private-party | Private-party |
| Buyer vetting | Profile-verified members | N/A | Anonymous strangers | Anonymous strangers |
| Scam-message detection | Yes — flagged at the inbox | N/A | Some — Meta filters | None |
| Time to sell | 5–14 days, priced right | Same day | Avg 14–30 days | Avg 21–45 days |
| Money handling | Direct, never touched by us | They wire / hand check | Direct | Direct |
| Title transfer help | State guide in dashboard | They handle it | None | None |
Built for sellers who don't want to get hosed.
5 steps, ~30 minutes upfront.
Want the full playbook? Read How to Sell Your Car Privately for More Than Carvana Will Pay →
Stop letting wholesale price your car.
List in five minutes. Free. Buyers see it the same day. Most cars priced right sell in under two weeks.
Create your listing →